Following a pivotal Supreme Court decision invalidating a portion of former President Trump's tariffs, numerous small business owners across the United States are left in a state of uncertainty, eagerly awaiting guidance on how to reclaim millions in overpaid duties. While the highest court has ruled these tariffs unconstitutional, the practical mechanism for reimbursement remains undefined, leaving entrepreneurs grappling with potential legal battles and administrative complexities to recover funds crucial for their operations and growth.
Alfred Mai, proprietor of ASM Games in San Francisco, which manufactures card games in China, estimates his company has incurred over $150,000 in tariffs now deemed unlawful. His immediate question, echoing that of countless other importers and retailers, is simple yet profound: "How do we get a refund?" The ruling, which nullified approximately $130 billion in tariffs, has sparked a frenzy of inquiries among businesses, trade groups, and legal experts, all seeking a clear path forward for repayments.
ASM Games, based in California, makes family card games such as "Do you really know your family." Its owner Alfred Mai has paid tens of thousands of dollars in tariffs that were struck down by the Supreme Court. ASM Games/AP hide caption
Initially, U.S. Customs and Border Protection continued to levy these tariffs even after the Supreme Court's pronouncement, causing alarm among businesses. However, the agency later announced its intention to cease collection, effective Tuesday. While a standard procedure for tariff refunds exists for clerical errors, legal counsel suggests that reclaiming these specific duties may necessitate direct litigation against the government, a daunting prospect for many small enterprises.
Sarah Wells, a Virginia-based entrepreneur specializing in accessories for new parents, expressed deep frustration with the lack of clear guidance. She has paid $35,000 in tariffs on goods from China and Cambodia and highlights the impracticality for small businesses to engage in time-consuming and expensive legal battles. Wells' story underscores the real-world impact of these policies, describing how tariff costs led to staff layoffs and product shortages, severely affecting her business.
Sarah Wells sells totes and backpacks for breast pumps, plus other products for new parents. She manufactures overseas for her Virginia-based company, Sarah Wells Bags. Courtesy of Sarah Wells hide caption
In response to the judicial decision, Senate Democrats have put forth legislation aimed at mandating tariff refunds, complete with interest, within 180 days, with a focus on assisting small businesses. Meanwhile, major corporations like Costco and Revlon have already initiated preemptive lawsuits for refunds, raising concerns among smaller businesses about securing their place in line. Danny Reynolds, who operates Stephenson's of Elkhart, an Indiana fashion store, questions whether his business will see any refunds, given that his suppliers, not his business directly, paid the tariffs.
Danny Reynolds relies on suppliers to import bridal gowns for sale at his Indiana store, Stephenson's of Elkhart. He wonders if those suppliers, who've charged him tariff fees, would send any refunds downstream to his business. Lily Miller hide caption
The established online platform, ACE, traditionally used for correcting customs errors, is seen by many business owners as a logical solution for processing these refunds. However, the system has experienced significant congestion, reflecting the widespread demand. Despite the existing infrastructure, the current administration has not indicated a willingness to utilize this system, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent deferring the refund issue to the courts and hinting at a potentially prolonged legal process. This lack of a clear, efficient refund mechanism leaves many businesses in limbo, unsure when, or if, they will recover their funds.
Alfred Mai, whose San Francisco-based business makes family card games in China, wonders if he'll need to hire a lawyer or a broker to get his tariff refunds. Courtesy of Alfred Mai hide caption
The recent Supreme Court ruling has created a complex situation for small businesses that bore the brunt of tariffs now deemed unconstitutional. While the legal groundwork for refunds has been laid, the practical implementation remains fraught with challenges. Businesses are calling for a transparent and accessible refund process, fearing that without clear government action, they may be forced into costly and lengthy legal battles to reclaim their dues. The outcome of this refund saga will significantly impact the financial health and future decisions of numerous small enterprises across the nation.
READ MORE
